Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery - Jenks, Oklahoma

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery: A Comprehensive Guide

For individuals seeking a delightful dining experience combining classic Italian flavors with indulgent frozen treats, Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery presents a compelling option. Located at 12141 S Elm St, Jenks, OK 74037, this establishment has garnered a significant following, evidenced by its impressive 497 reviews on Google My Business and an average opinion of 4.4 out of 5. It operates as a multifaceted dining destination, offering a comprehensive menu that caters to a wide range of palates and preferences. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is apparent in its diverse service offerings and accessible environment.

Restaurant Overview

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a destination where patrons can enjoy freshly made pizzas, delectable ice cream, and a taste of authentic Italian cuisine. The establishment skillfully blends these three core concepts, creating a unique and satisfying experience. The ambiance is generally described as casual, cozy, and trendy, making it suitable for both informal gatherings and solo dining experiences. The restaurant’s layout includes dedicated spaces for various dining needs, including comfortable seating arrangements, high chairs for children, and a welcoming counter service area for a quick bite.

Menu Highlights & Specialties

The menu at Gaetano’s is thoughtfully curated, encompassing a wide selection of options. The pizza restaurant portion of the business is undoubtedly a key draw, with a rotating selection of both traditional and specialty pizzas. Customers frequently rave about their sausage pizza, often ordering the personal pizza lunch special for its deliciousness and value. Beyond pizza, the ice cream shop offers a tempting array of frozen desserts, providing a sweet conclusion to any meal. Furthermore, the restaurant operates as a full-fledged Italian restaurant, serving classic pasta dishes, appetizers, and other Italian specialties. Notably, the establishment offers vegan and vegetarian options, demonstrating a commitment to inclusivity and catering to diverse dietary needs. The small plates and comfort food selections are also popular, providing a range of options for sharing and individual enjoyment.

Services and Amenities

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery provides a comprehensive range of services to enhance the dining experience. Delivery is available, allowing customers to enjoy their favorite meals at home. Onsite services include takeout and dine-in options, catering to varying preferences. The restaurant prides itself on fast service, ensuring a prompt and efficient dining experience. The operating hours cater to both lunch and dinner crowds, and the restaurant welcomes solo diners, groups, and those seeking reservations.

Convenience is further enhanced by the acceptance of various payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. The restaurant is fully equipped to handle transactions securely and efficiently. Accessibility is a priority, with features such as a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating. Free parking lot and free street parking are available to patrons. The establishment also offers dessert, contributing to a complete and satisfying dining experience. A counter service option provides a quick and convenient way to order and enjoy smaller items.

Location and Contact Information

Visitors can easily locate Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery at 12141 S Elm St, Jenks, OK 74037. For inquiries or reservations, they can contact the restaurant at Phone: 82981122. The website, gaetanospizza.net, offers further details about the menu, hours of operation, and special events. The website also provides a convenient way to place online orders and make reservations.

Customer Feedback and Overall Impression

The positive customer feedback – with an average rating of 4.4/5 and 497 reviews – speaks volumes about the quality of food and service at Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery. While some reviewers noted inconsistencies in food preparation (some meals microwaved, others fresh), the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. Many customers consistently praise the sausage pizza and the personal pizza lunch special. The friendly and attentive server staff is frequently mentioned as a highlight of the dining experience. The restaurant’s commitment to accessibility, with features like wheelchair access, makes it a welcoming environment for all patrons. The inclusion of high chairs and a kids' menu further enhances its appeal to families. The ability to accommodate groups and accept reservations adds to its convenience and desirability. The casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere, coupled with the comfort food offerings and quick bite options, makes Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery a popular choice for a wide range of diners.

👍 Reviews of Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery

Addison B.

3/5

The best part of the menu was the dessert. Some of the meals we received seemed to be microwaved while others seemed fresh. The dry pasta was served at the same time as the one with sauce. Appetizers came after the meal, and some of our group waited 45+ for appetizers. Server was super sweet but the food just seemed be reheated and not homemade.

Emma F.

5/5

I absolutely love their sausage pizza. I get the personal pizza lunch special and it’s so delicious. I highly recommend if you would like good pizza and want to support a small business!

Joanett B.

5/5

I AM STUFFED! Oh my lord I had some delicious pizza! The manager was such a nice young gentleman bless his heart! It goes to show there’s still good young workers out there! His future wife will be very pleased! Will definitely have to give my self a little ice cream treat sometime when Ive done some good!

corrado L. (.

5/5

Ok first time visit, I should have gotten the name of the woman at the counter, she’s a delight! Not only was she super pleasant but she 1000% was trying to get what I ordered put on the menu! So what we ordered was the bacon cheeseburger calzone but as a pizza. If you want to do this here’s my suggestion take the 1000 island dressing from their salads use as sauce base add meats and cheese and cook, maybe butter the crust and add sesame seeds at end of bake.
Seriously those pizza rolls are KILLER, nice size, full of flavor and pepperoni and dusted with delicious Italian seasonings!
We both ate 2 rolls and 2 slices, went home with leftovers and don’t even need dinner tonight.
The service is so GOOD HERE.
Please forgive my photos I remembered to take them after I had already snatched a couple rolls and the pizza slices but seriously don’t sleep on this place. Their menu is limited but very well executed and they also have ICE CREAM!!!!
Clean space, clean restrooms, plenty of seating and more than ample parking!
We will definitely be back!!!

Brian R.

5/5

They have well above average pizza, and the ice cream is amazing. Given the quick pizza choices around here, they are 100% my go to. Add a pint of “Heaps of Love” please! Oh wait…the peppermint stick is out now? Add that too…

Ashton B.

5/5

Absolutely the best hand tossed cheese pizza that I've ever had. And the garlic knots are a must. 4 stars for service because the few times I've called I was on hold for quite a while (but every time my husband calls he gets through immediately.)

isabella W.

5/5

Sooo good! Pizza was fresh and very delicious and the pepperoni rolls were fluffy and cheesy. The ice cream was light and creamy, I recommend the ‘fat elvis’ flavor if you like banana

Kyle G.

5/5

We love our local Gaetanos pizza shop. I’m from Pittsburgh and love the Pittsburgh sports memorabilia they have out and the themed pizzas. The pizzas are the best in town and the staff is super friendly.